Sharing Equally the Toil and Its Rewards
Painting by Ilya Repin "Ploughman" Tolstoy working in the fields
Early in the first part of Lev Nikolayevich Tolstoy's great novel, "Anna Karenina", we see Konstantin Levin (the character I most identified with) paying a visit to his old boyhood friend Oblonsky at the government office where Oblonsky holds an official position.
Levin is physically well-built, strong and tall, but he feels awkward, inarticulate and out of place in the sophisticated ministerial environment into which he has ventured.
Oblonsky introduces him to his colleagues who are present. Quote:
"Levin was silent, looking at the unfamiliar faces of Oblonsky's two colleagues and especially at the hands of the elegant Grinevich who had very long, white fingers with very long, yellowish nails curving up at the points and large glittering sleeve-links. These hands apparently absorbed all Levin's attention, depriving him of freedom of thought."
These
hands with their
"long, yellowish nails" and Levin's reaction to them, set the tone for one of the major themes in Tolstoy's novel. The hands that belong to an official of the ruling class are pampered hands which have never known strenuous toil.
Levin, like Count Leo Tolstoy himself, was born into an aristocratic Russian family and has inherited an estate with numerous serfs. His advantages afford him the opportunity to live an idle and dissipated life among the wealthy and titled people of Petersburg and Moscow. He probably could become a government official, another Grinevich, if he so wishes. He feels, however, a strong aversion to such privilege, finding deeper satisfaction in managing his estate. He is drawn to the countryside, to the land, to the peasants who support society with their work.
 |
| Young Leo Tolstoy |
Leo Tolstoy spent his early years bouncing around from university to his estate, to society and into the army without much clear purpose or direction. He drifted into the dissolute life of a carouser and a wastrel but increasingly, he found a personal anchor in writing. Associating with the literati of Russia and Europe gratified his vanity but he began to see something false and hollow in the intellectual vocation.
Much later in his life he looked back with some shame and a great deal of regret on the wayward folly of his behavior as a young man. He described this earlier period with the following harsh words:
"I put men to death in war, I fought duels to slay others. I lost at cards, wasted the substance wrung from the sweat of peasants, punished the latter cruelly, rioted with loose women, and deceived men. Lying, robbery, adultery of all kinds, drunkenness, violence, and murder, all were committed by me, not one crime omitted, and yet I was not the less considered by my equals to be a comparatively moral man. Such was my life for ten years."
Leo Tolstoy
"My Confession" 1880
As realization gradually dawned in Tolstoy's mind that the social structure within which his own life was so amply supported was based on grievous injustice and violence, he determined not only to reform his own life and the socio-economic conditions on his estate, but to work out ways that society at large might best be reformed.
We can find in the novel, reflections of the author's growing social awareness:
Nicholas Levin to his brother Konstantine:
"... our society has so shaped itself that the more the people work the richer the merchants and landowners will become, while the people will remain beasts of burden for ever. And this system must be changed."
Later, Konstantine's thoughts about his brother's ideas:
"...he had always felt the injustice of his own superfluities compared with the peasant's poverty, and now decided, in order to feel quite justified, that though he had always worked hard and lived simply, he would in future work still more and allow himself still less luxury. And it all seemed to him so easy to carry out..."
Neither the real Tolstoy nor the fictional Levin found that reforms were "easy to carry out". After so many centuries of serfdom, the farm workers didn't understand much about independence and felt little trust for the landlord and his newfangled ideas.
* * * * *
Tolstoy the great writer was, above all, a dedicated thinker. Throughout his years he grappled mightily with the important questions of his own time and perhaps of all time. Brought to depression and suicidal despair by the relentless exercise of reason, he turned to the church for relief through faith. He soon rejected the absurdities of institutional religion, hammering out his own idiosyncratic version of Christianity emphasizing the core teachings of Jesus as expressed in the sermon on the mount.
 |
| From: "Reciprocity, Or the Golden Rule, Tolstoy |
Tolstoy pondered the "Golden Rule" as taught by Jesus:
Matthew 7:12: “So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you, for this sums up the Law and the Prophets.” and he took it very seriously indeed.
Unlike K"ung Tzu who meant to re-establish and solidify the traditional hierarchical structure of his society, Tolstoy, so many centuries later, wished to use reciprocal ethics to break down hierarchies of power, privilege and wealth and to bring about egalitarian reform.
His belief that uncompromising adherence to this principle of reciprocal ethics was "the answer" subsequently brought Tolstoy to unpopular and dangerous positions. He became an outspoken advocate of non-violence, a pacifist opposed to patriotism and state warfare, capital punishment, and violent revolution. He became an
anarchist
opposed to government and to taxation. He spoke forcefully against institutional religion and was excommunicated by the Russian Orthodox Church.
He even became a vegetarian.
Late in his life Tolstoy took on the role of demagogue, attempting, in his didactic writing, to persuade wealthy and idle people to share their property with working people, give up luxury and learn to work for their own sustenance. The extremism of his ideas and his moralizing tone limited his effectiveness, I think. He convinced a few, influenced many but tended to offend and alienate most, including his wife and family members.
* * * * *
But the equal sharing of toil
and its rewards isn't only an issue of social/economic justice. By the sweat of the worker's brow,
rewards that go far beyond mere bread and other material goods may be realized. Spending time in purposeful exertion out in the fresh air and sunlight, in contact with the natural world, bestows good health, substantial pleasure and deep satisfaction. I have found through personal experience that these rewards of toil are very real and very valuable.
In the wonderful section of Anna Karenina in which Levin decides to join his peasants in their day's work mowing a large hay-meadow Tolstoy reveals this other aspect; the exhilarating joy of physical work.
 |
| "Haymaking" Yuri Kuznetsov |
At first the peasants are uneasy about having their "Master" working alongside them and Levin finds that the work of swinging the long scythe is hard for him. Persevering, he slips into a rhythm and a state of self-forgetfulness as the day progresses. He gets to know the simple and good-hearted peasants and they, in turn, accept him into their company with helpful and generous good humor.
In the heat of the day, Levin experiences the blissful enjoyment of an ordinary drink of water:
"And truly Levin had never tasted any drink so good as this warm water with bits of grass floating in it and a rusty flavor from the tin dipper."
There is indeed a truly Epicurean pleasure in simple food when hungry and fatigued, in setting down the heavy pack after hiking 10 miles over hill and dale and just lying down on the bare ground, rest is blissful. Similarly, simple friendship with companions who have shared the effort toward a common goal is pleasure surpassing any concert or sumptuous entertainment.
"If the life of a man is filled with toil, and if he knows the
delights of rest, he requires no chambers, furniture, and rich and varied clothing; he requires less costly food; he needs no means of locomotion, or of diversion. But the principal thing is, that the man who regards labor as the business and the joy of his life will not seek that relief from his labor which the labors of others might afford him."
Leo Tolstoy: "On Labor and Luxury"
"The possibility Of living On the land, of gaining one's sustenance from it by means of one's own labor, has always been and always will be one of the chief conditions of a happy and independent human life."
Leo Tolstoy; "To The Working People"
 |
| Russian Peasants by Anne Bobroff-Hajal
|